The Poems of T. S. Eliot : Collected and Uncollected Poems Volume 1

"These volumes are not merely a monument to T. S. Eliot, they are a blazing demonstration of what literary criticism, at its best, can do for literature."

"Monumental... In taking apart Eliot's poems to show where the parts came from, The Poems of T. S. Eliot: The Annotated Text demonstrates that it never was the parts which mattered, but the elusive magic which made up the whole machine."

"These volumes force a reevaluation of the highs and lows of Eliot's gifts, one that will supersede earlier, outmoded interpretations of racism, anti-Semitism, and sexual inhibition and avowals of elitist or conservative slants... Essential."

"With the printing of this edition of Eliot's poems... one might say that we are just getting to know the Old Possum properly."

"Two all-comprehending new tomes... utterly authoritative."

"... So comprehensive and authoritative that one can't imagine their [the editors' notes and commentaries] being superseded..."

"... One of the great achievements in the literary scholarship of our time."