Verwandte Artikel zu War Stories: The Causes and Consequences of Public...

War Stories: The Causes and Consequences of Public Views of War - Softcover

Baum, Matthew A.; Groeling, Tim J.

 
9780691138596: War Stories: The Causes and Consequences of Public Views of War

Inhaltsangabe

How does the American public formulate its opinions about U.S. foreign policy and military engagement abroad? War Stories argues that the media systematically distort the information the public vitally needs to determine whether to support such initiatives, for reasons having more to do with journalists' professional interests than the merits of the policies, and that this has significant consequences for national security. Matthew Baum and Tim Groeling develop a "strategic bias" theory that explains the foreign-policy communication process as a three-way interaction among the press, political elites, and the public, each of which has distinct interests, biases, and incentives.


Do media representations affect public support for the president and faithfully reflect events in times of diplomatic crisis and war? How do new media--especially Internet news and more partisan outlets--shape public opinion, and how will they alter future conflicts? In answering such questions, Baum and Groeling take an in-depth look at media coverage, elite rhetoric, and public opinion during the Iraq war and other U.S. conflicts abroad. They trace how traditional and new media select stories, how elites frame and sometimes even distort events, and how these dynamics shape public opinion over the course of a conflict.


Most of us learn virtually everything we know about foreign policy from media reporting of elite opinions. In War Stories, Baum and Groeling reveal precisely what this means for the future of American foreign policy.

Die Inhaltsangabe kann sich auf eine andere Ausgabe dieses Titels beziehen.

Über die Autorin bzw. den Autor

Matthew A. Baum is the Marvin Kalb Professor of Global Communications and professor of public policy and government at Harvard University. Tim J. Groeling is associate professor of communication studies at the University of California, Los Angeles.

Von der hinteren Coverseite

"War Stories will have a major impact on how scholars think about media influences on foreign policymaking in the United States. Baum and Groeling have produced a credible, comprehensive, and consistent analysis of why journalists cover foreign policy in a skewed fashion and how this ultimately affects public opinion about conflicts such as the Iraq war."--James T. Hamilton, Duke University

"War Stories makes a significant contribution to our knowledge of how the strategic decisions of politicians, parties, and news organizations shape the information about conflicts that is conveyed to the public. Baum and Groeling contend that media rhetoric greatly influences public opinion in times of war regardless of the empirical reality such as casualties and events. This book addresses an important topic."--Diana Owen, Georgetown University

Auszug. © Genehmigter Nachdruck. Alle Rechte vorbehalten.

War Stories

THE CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCES OF PUBLIC VIEWS OF WARBy Matthew A. Baum Tim J. Groeling

PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS

Copyright © 2010 Princeton University Press
All right reserved.

ISBN: 978-0-691-13859-6

Contents

List of Figures.........................................................................................................................................................ixList of Tables..........................................................................................................................................................xiiiPreface.................................................................................................................................................................xvAcknowledgments.........................................................................................................................................................xviiChapter One News, Opinion, and Foreign Policy..........................................................................................................................1Chapter Two Politics across the Water's Edge...........................................................................................................................17Chapter Three Elite Rhetoric, Media Coverage, and Rallying 'Round the Flag.............................................................................................46Chapter Four War Meets the Press: Strategic Media Bias and Elite Foreign Policy Evaluations............................................................................89Chapter Five Shot by the Messenger: An Experimental Examination of the Effects of Party Cues on Public Opinion Regarding National Security and War.....................114Chapter Six Tidings of Battle: Polarizing Media and Public Support for the Iraq War....................................................................................149Chapter Seven "Reality Asserted Itself": The Elasticity of Reality and the War in Iraq.................................................................................186Chapter Eight Barbarians inside the Gates: Partisan New Media and the Polarization of American Political Discourse.....................................................230Chapter Nine Back to the Future: Foreign Policy in the Second Era of the Partisan Press................................................................................284References..............................................................................................................................................................297Index...................................................................................................................................................................315

Chapter One

News, Opinion, and Foreign Policy

On August 21, 2005, Senators Chuck Hagel (R-NE) and George Allen (R-VA) appeared together on the ABC Sunday morning political roundtable program This Week to discuss American involvement in Iraq. The senators were of comparable stature; both were considered credible aspirants for the 2008 Republican presidential nomination, both were forceful and articulate for their respective positions, and both spoke for similar lengths of time. Yet they differed in one key respect: Hagel criticized U.S. policy in Iraq, while Allen defended it. Commenting on the Bush administration's just released proposal to "possibly" keep over 100,000 troops in Iraq "for at least four more years," Hagel scoffed: "I think that it's just complete folly.... The fact is I don't know where he's going to get these troops ... there won't be any National Guard left.... No Army Reserve left.... There's no way America is going to have 100,000 troops in Iraq, nor should it, in four years. It would bog us down, it would further destabilize the Middle East ... we need to be out." Allen responded by defending the proposal: "This was a worst case scenario. And I think that ... if they can constitute a free and just society with this constitution that they're working on right now, I think that that will be something, a real measurement, a real benchmark that Chuck [Hagel] talks about."

We have recounted this anecdote on numerous occasions to audiences of students, scholars, and journalists. In each instance, we asked the audience to guess which senator's comments were broadcast on the network news that evening. Without exception, most of our audience members-and frequently all of them-anticipated that post-interview media coverage would heavily emphasize Hagel and largely ignore Allen. In this respect, our audiences were prescient: in the two weeks following the interview, journalists broadcast over 30 times more television stories about Hagel's criticism of the war than about Allen's defense of it. What accounts for the vast difference in media attention devoted to these prominent Republicans' comments? Clearly, many people-indeed, nearly everyone to whom we have ever posed the question-intuitively assume that the news media prefer to cover criticism of the president's Iraq War policy over support for it, at least when the critique is offered by a senator from the president's own party. However, as intuitive as this assumption may be, the prevailing views of the causes and consequences of public support for foreign policy, both in Washington and in the academy, have failed to consider this common assumption and its implications. In this respect, the coverage of Hagel and Allen illustrates an important limitation to our understanding of the dynamics of public support for American foreign policy. That is, the information on which the public depends in determining whether or not to support a foreign policy initiative may be systematically distorted for reasons having more to do with the professional incentives of journalists than with the merits of the policy. This limitation has important consequences both for understanding whether and when the public is likely to support the president in times of foreign conflicts and for assessing the likely implications of public opinion for the political viability and sustainability of military actions under different circumstances.

The goals of this book are first, to identify the conditions under which the American public will or will not support their president when he or she leads the nation to war; second, to determine precisely when those conditions will tend to prevail (and for how long); and third, to assess their implications for the future of American foreign policy.

To accomplish these goals, we focus on the primary source of public information about politics and foreign policy, the mass media. The mass media are the key intermediaries between citizens and their leaders, particularly with respect to policies and events being implemented far from American shores. Citizens learn virtually everything they know about foreign policy from the mass media, whether through direct personal exposure or indirectly, via conversations with friends or family members who gained their information from the media. This makes understanding how the media select stories concerning foreign policy (the supply of information) central to any effort to account for public attitudes toward those policies (the demand for policy).

This focus in turn leads us to three central questions that guide this book. First, to what extent do the media's representations of foreign policy rhetoric and events account for variations in public support for presidential foreign policy initiatives, and do these effects vary over the...

„Über diesen Titel“ kann sich auf eine andere Ausgabe dieses Titels beziehen.