Fixing Men: Sex, Birth Control, and AIDS in Mexico - Softcover

Gutmann, Matthew C. C.

 
9780520253308: Fixing Men: Sex, Birth Control, and AIDS in Mexico

Inhaltsangabe

Most studies on reproductive rights make women their focus, but in Fixing Men, Matthew Gutmann illuminates what men in the Mexican state of Oaxaca say and do about contraception, sex, and AIDS. Based on extensive fieldwork, this breakthrough study by a preeminent anthropologist of men and masculinities reveals how these men and the women in their lives make decisions about birth control, how they cope with the plague of AIDS, and the contradictory healing techniques biomedical and indigenous medical practitioners employ for infertility, impotence, and infidelity. Gutmann talks with men during and after their vasectomies and discovers why some opt for sterilization while so many others feel "planned out of family planning."

Die Inhaltsangabe kann sich auf eine andere Ausgabe dieses Titels beziehen.

Über die Autorin bzw. den Autor

Matthew Gutmann is Professor of Anthropology, Ethnic Studies, and Latin American Studies at Brown University and is the author of The Meanings of Macho: Being a Man in Mexico City (Tenth Anniversary edition, 2006) and The Romance of Democracy: Compliant Defiance in Contemporary Mexico (2002), both from UC Press.

Von der hinteren Coverseite

"Fixing Men is terrific; sharp observation, tough-minded analysis, beautiful writing."—Raewyn Connell, author of Masculinities

"By bringing together a focus on men's sexuality in relation to key sexual health issues such as HIV/AIDS, family planning and contraception, vasectomies, and traditional healing for sexual ailments such as impotence and infertility, Fixing Men makes a major contribution that should help to define the field for some time to come."—Richard Parker, author of Beneath the Equator: Cultures of Desire, Male Homosexuality, and Emerging Gay Communities in Brazil

"This ethnographic study of male sexuality, reproductive health and health behavior makes new and needed contribution to several scholarly debates and literatures. It is certain to attract interest from medical anthropologists, along with researchers on gender, sexuality, Mexican studies, and reproductive health."—Carole Browner, University of California, Los Angeles

"In this consistently engaging study of male reproductive health, Matt Gutmann has produced an original contribution to Latin American ethnography, the study of masculinity, and medical anthropology. Gutmann listens carefully to the life stories of men in Oaxaca and discovers among them a rich range of emotions, opinions, and behavior. As with his previous influential work, Fixing Men presents a serious challenge to stereotypical portraits of what it means to be a man in Mexico. Once you start reading this riveting volume, you will not be able to put it down."—Stanley Brandes, University of California, Berkeley

"Matthew Gutmann draws on his magisterial understanding of Mexican masculinities in demonstrating how taking male subjectivities and migration seriously can illuminate the dynamics of HIV/AIDS and reproductive health. In Fixing Men, a conspiracy of silence recedes in the face of his dialogues with Oaxacan men, whose words, labor, and bodies challenge the cultural, sexual, and neoliberal logics that have enabled scholars and public health practitioners alike to avoid these complex questions."—Charles Briggs, author of Stories in the Time of Cholera

"Fixing Men is a path-breaking study of men's reproductive health in Latin America. In a scholarly field where the focus is almost entirely on women, Fixing Men shows us that men are important reproductive actors, whose problems, needs, and desires must be addressed in the fields of family planning, sex education, and HIV/AIDS. This book represents an important contribution to the anthropology of reproduction, the new masculinity studies, and to Oaxacan ethnography. Global health practitioners would also benefit from Gutmann's insights about the need to address men directly in reproductive healthcare delivery."—Marcia C. Inhorn, author of Local Babies, Global Science

Aus dem Klappentext

"Fixing Men is terrific; sharp observation, tough-minded analysis, beautiful writing."Raewyn Connell, author of Masculinities

"By bringing together a focus on men's sexuality in relation to key sexual health issues such as HIV/AIDS, family planning and contraception, vasectomies, and traditional healing for sexual ailments such as impotence and infertility, Fixing Men makes a major contribution that should help to define the field for some time to come."Richard Parker, author of Beneath the Equator: Cultures of Desire, Male Homosexuality, and Emerging Gay Communities in Brazil

"This ethnographic study of male sexuality, reproductive health and health behavior makes new and needed contribution to several scholarly debates and literatures. It is certain to attract interest from medical anthropologists, along with researchers on gender, sexuality, Mexican studies, and reproductive health."Carole Browner, University of California, Los Angeles

"In this consistently engaging study of male reproductive health, Matt Gutmann has produced an original contribution to Latin American ethnography, the study of masculinity, and medical anthropology. Gutmann listens carefully to the life stories of men in Oaxaca and discovers among them a rich range of emotions, opinions, and behavior. As with his previous influential work, Fixing Men presents a serious challenge to stereotypical portraits of what it means to be a man in Mexico. Once you start reading this riveting volume, you will not be able to put it down."Stanley Brandes, University of California, Berkeley

"Matthew Gutmann draws on his magisterial understanding of Mexican masculinities in demonstrating how taking male subjectivities and migration seriously can illuminate the dynamics of HIV/AIDS and reproductive health. In Fixing Men, a conspiracy of silence recedes in the face of his dialogues with Oaxacan men, whose words, labor, and bodies challenge the cultural, sexual, and neoliberal logics that have enabled scholars and public health practitioners alike to avoid these complex questions."Charles Briggs, author of Stories in the Time of Cholera

"Fixing Men is a path-breaking study of men's reproductive health in Latin America. In a scholarly field where the focus is almost entirely on women, Fixing Men shows us that men are important reproductive actors, whose problems, needs, and desires must be addressed in the fields of family planning, sex education, and HIV/AIDS. This book represents an important contribution to the anthropology of reproduction, the new masculinity studies, and to Oaxacan ethnography. Global health practitioners would also benefit from Gutmann's insights about the need to address men directly in reproductive healthcare delivery."Marcia C. Inhorn, author of Local Babies, Global Science

Auszug. © Genehmigter Nachdruck. Alle Rechte vorbehalten.

Fixing Men

Sex, Birth Control, and AIDS in MexicoBy Matthew Gutmann

University of California Press

Copyright © 2007 The Regents of the University of California
All right reserved.

ISBN: 978-0-520-25330-8

Contents

List of Illustrations......................................................................ixAcknowledgments............................................................................xi1. Taming Men's Natural Desires in Oaxaca..................................................12. The Missing Gamete: Eight Common Mistakes about Men's Sexuality.........................283. New Labyrinths of Solitude: Lonesome Men and AIDS.......................................474. Frisky and Risky Men: AIDS Care in Oaxaca...............................................715. Planning Men Out of Family Planning.....................................................1006. Scoring Men: Vasectomies and the Totemic Illusion of Male Sexuality.....................1307. Traditional Sexual Healing of Men.......................................................1658. From Boardrooms to Bedrooms.............................................................196Notes......................................................................................213Bibliography...............................................................................231Index......................................................................................255

Chapter One

Taming Men's Natural Desires in Oaxaca At the bedrock of our [Western] culture's thinking about sexuality is the assumption that a given pattern of sexuality is native to the human constitution. R. W. Connell and G. W. Dowsett (1992:50)

"Well, you know, they did it to me a few years ago...." That is how I began my interviews with men who wanted vasectomies in Oaxaca, conducted during their operations. It seemed to break the ice and get the men talking. They told me why they decided to get sterilized, about discussions they had had with their wives before the procedure, and, invariably, about anxieties as to what would happen with their postoperative sexual desire and performance. Sometimes a man would get jumpy and I would excuse myself. The last thing the poor guy needed was to be interviewed, I assumed. But the doctors and the men themselves would insist, "No, stick around!" I became the anthropologist-as-emotional-anesthesiologist.

Vasectomies were not common in the mountainous provincial capital of Oaxaca, in southern Mexico. But I was not looking for common men-whatever that term might mean. I wanted to know why men who got sterilized decided to do so. The answer turned out to be deceptively straightforward. For many, if not all, of the men I spoke with in Oaxaca, the most common explanation for getting vasectomies was that their wives had already suffered enough-taking birth control for years, getting pregnant, giving birth-and now it was their turn. When I asked these same men why they had long relied on their wives to use contraceptives in the past, and why they had not used a male form of birth control, the men responded with a simple incredulous question: "Like what? The condom?" In Oaxaca, as elsewhere in the world, most artificial, modern forms of contraception-and all the most reliable ones-are for women. The men asked me if I thought they had much of a choice about what form of birth control to use. I responded honestly that the choices available to the men of Oaxaca were part of a larger picture that involved, among others, the international pharmaceutical industry that develops and manufactures birth control devices and medications. Unless a modern contraceptive is made and marketed by these companies, it will not be available in Oaxaca or anywhere else in the contemporary world.

International pharmaceuticals were also involved in the lives of other men I spent time with in Oaxaca, those who traveled to the United States as migrant workers, became infected with HIV while living there in new labyrinths of solitude, and returned home, whereupon they infected wives and girlfriends. When I lived in Oaxaca on and off in the period 2001-05, fewer than two hundred men and women received the life-saving antiretrovirals manufactured by the multinational drug companies and sold to the state-run clinic in Oaxaca. Unlike some countries in the world, in Mexico the government health sector paid the pharmaceutical companies top prices for AIDS medications. As a result, thousands of men and women in Oaxaca who were HIV+ or had AIDS were inevitably going to face premature deaths, many without ever knowing what disease was killing them. I spent time with these dying patients, and I attended the Wednesday-morning meetings with the medical personnel where decisions were made about exactly which men and women would be given the drugs and who was doomed to an early demise.

In Oaxaca, doctors said the migrant men had become infected with HIV after having sex with other men in the United States. When I asked one doctor how he knew this and why he was so sure, he told me, "That's what Mexican men do: they have sex with other men." When I asked him if he had sex with men, he looked startled. When I asked if his father or brother or son or uncle or neighbor had sex with other men, he began to get annoyed. It turned out that a lot of what passed for knowledge in this realm was based on common sense and cultural folk wisdom. The notion of "men's natural sexual desires" was blamed for a host of health problems like AIDS in Oaxaca. And if these generalizations were not necessarily accurate for all men-"That's just the way men are!"-then at least they were true for men who grew up in Mexico. Mexican culture and Mexican male culture were considered the culprits in many a Mexican medical schema.

Surprisingly to me, the medical people who seemed least taken with dichotomous views of men's sexuality and women's sexuality as entirely and naturally distinct were the men and women who called themselves traditional indigenous midwives and healers. From these mdicos tradicionales I also heard of techniques that women can employ to keep their men from straying, and I learned why men go on sexual diets after their wives give birth. In distant rural communities along the coast and in the mountains of the state I often discovered a far more expansive and self-conscious understanding of what culture means for the diagnosis and healing of illness than I heard in the various biomedical clinics in Oaxaca City where I spent time.

My arrival in Oaxaca coincided with efforts launched from Mexico City-and the implementation of an earlier 1993 report by the World Bank-ordering that health care throughout the country be further privatized and decentralized. These stringent measures further exacerbated an already inadequate situation in providing care to those most in need, which in Oaxaca nearly always means the nearly two million indigenous people, most of whom live in poverty and some in extreme poverty. The conditions of poverty and miserable health care are the same as those that propel so many people to try their luck as migrant workers in the United States. Seen in this context of scarcity and suffering, issues of impotence, infertility, and infidelity among men might seem inconsequential. I can only affirm that none of the men and women with whom I spent time in Oaxaca from 2001 to 2005 belittled my questions about sex, birth control, and AIDS.

MEN AND WOMEN TAKING POLITICS PERSONALLY

Many studies on reproduction to date have focused on women. This...

„Über diesen Titel“ kann sich auf eine andere Ausgabe dieses Titels beziehen.

Weitere beliebte Ausgaben desselben Titels

9780520252622: Fixing Men: Sex, Birth Control, and AIDS in Mexico

Vorgestellte Ausgabe

ISBN 10:  0520252624 ISBN 13:  9780520252622
Verlag: University of California Press, 2007
Hardcover